Take the 90 sec. Quiz to find out what's holding back your success

The Danger of Chasing Every New Idea in Your Business

The Danger of Chasing Every New Idea in Your Business

Stop Shooting from the Hip: A Small Business Strategy for Slow Sales

When sales slow down, it’s tempting to try anything that might bring customers. But chasing trends and constantly changing direction can create more problems than it solves.

In episode 342 of The Main Street CEO, Theresa Cantley shares a small business strategy for slow sales that replaces panic with purpose.

As Main Street businesses prepare for the holiday season, she offers three priorities: stay true to your core, test intentionally, and remember your people.

 

What You’ll Learn in This Episode

  • Why copying competitors can weaken what makes your business unique.
  • How financial and marketing metrics reveal where to focus.
  • Why testing one thing at a time protects your profit.
  • How to support your team during a demanding season.

 

Stay True to Your Core

More offerings don’t automatically mean more revenue, and more revenue doesn’t automatically mean more profit.

Theresa describes a vendor that moved away from its distinctive, niche products toward mainstream offerings as business slowed. The changes didn’t deliver the results the vendor expected. Instead of investigating what was working, the business drifted from its core.

Her advice?

Become a better puzzle solver. Review your financials, product profitability, and marketing metrics. Look for the story they tell, then go deeper on what already works rather than copying everyone else and disappearing into a sea of sameness.

 

Test Intentionally, Then Measure

Experimentation belongs in entrepreneurship, but constant experimentation shouldn’t become your default operating mode.

Theresa recommends testing one thing at a time and giving it enough time to produce meaningful results.

She recalls a friend’s advice to allow at least 90 days and explains why constantly tweaking search engine optimization makes it difficult to see what’s working.

The essential step is measurement. Test, measure, make a small adjustment, and measure again before deciding whether to continue or change direction.

Remember that new products, menu changes, training, and waste all carry costs. Unchecked testing can quietly consume the profit you’re trying to protect.

 

Remember Your People

Every sudden change asks your team to switch gears. Too many competing priorities leave people frustrated, confused, and unsure how their work contributes to the bigger picture.

During the holidays, those pressures compound personal commitments. Theresa encourages owners to ask: “What matters most to you this season?” Then find ways to honor the answers.

 

Key Takeaways

A stronger business doesn’t come from doing everything. It comes from protecting what makes you different, measuring thoughtful experiments, and caring for the people who bring your business to life.

Listen to episode 342 for Theresa’s guidance on leading with clarity instead of reacting out of fear.

 

Download the full episode transcript

Episode Transcript

The Main Street CEO with Theresa Cantley

Episode: Stay True to Your Core (Live, October 1)

Runtime: approximately 17 minutes

Accessibility note: This transcript is provided for deaf and hard-of-hearing listeners and anyone who prefers to read. It has been lightly edited for readability, removing repeated words and false starts. Non-speech sounds are noted in brackets. No meaning has been changed.

Speakers

Theresa Cantley, host, Business Advisor and Author

Transcript

Theresa Cantley (00:00:01)

Hello, and happy October 1st. Oh my gosh, it’s fall, it’s October 1st, and we are headed into a busy season. So thank you for joining me this afternoon. In case this is the first time that you’ve been here, I am Theresa Cantley, and I am a business advisor for established Main Street businesses. And I have

been having lots of conversations recently with people, just because this year has not exactly gone the way that people expected it to. And we talk about this a lot. If you listen to my podcast, which is now called The Main Street CEO, formerly The C-Suite Mentor, I talk about this, about just different things that have been happening this year. Buying behavior has shifted.

There’s all kinds of stuff going on with increased costs, the tariffs, I mean, you name it, and it’s made an impact across the board. And I’ve had a conversation with many different business owners, different vendors that I work with, where everyone has said, “Theresa, it’s been a weird year. It’s been slower than normal, and we have been trying

all kinds of things.” And just, you know, “We see something and we want to try that, and we see something, we want to try this.” And they’re like, “You know, it’s just been slow.” And I wanted to talk about this because what happens, and I’ve seen it as a pattern for many, many, many years, is that when things are slow, panic sets in. When revenue is down, panic sets in. When our profit is off, panic sets in.

And when panic sets in, we start getting into, as my mother used to say when I was growing up, shooting from the hip. And we end up doing a lot of random stuff, stuff that doesn’t necessarily align with the plan that we started out with in the beginning of the year. So I wanted to talk about it because, again, we’re headed into a busy season. And as much as we get into shooting from the hip

(00:02:26)

when it’s slow and we’re trying, we get into that panic mode of, we just want to get more foot traffic, we just want to get more cash flow, we just, you know, want to get more customers. We head into that mindset. And when we head into the busy season and we shoot from the hip, then we start to create more chaos for our people. And we don’t want to do that.

Right. Because when we create chaos for our people with thousands of ideas we’re bringing to the business, it creates a lot more that we have to then navigate, which we’re going to talk about. So I’m going to give you a few things to think about as we head into this next season. And maybe you’ve been saying you’ve been shooting from the hip. Maybe you’ve been just trying anything and everything. I mean, I know people that are using AI heavily to create

content, to create things in their business to run. I had someone that I talked to the other day, and they said, “Yeah, I had ChatGPT create me a business plan.” And I was like, “Really? How’d that work for you?” Because you can’t just blindly put it in there and expect to get something absolutely amazing out of it, and that you end up following blindly, which people do. That’s a whole other conversation. So I’m going to give you some things to think about, because like I said,

we head into this busy season, which, if you’re in the hospitality industry, if you’re in the retail industry, and I think really it’s kind of across the board, it just tends to be a very busy season. And chaos can set in very quickly. So the one thing I want you to think about, whether you’re thinking, “It’s been really slow, we don’t know what to do.

We’re just going to try anything. We saw this that this person was doing, so we’re just going to mimic it.” The one thing I want you to think about is stay true to your core. Always stay true to your core. So it’s very classic that when it’s slow, we want to try anything and everything. So we have a vendor that we work with, and they have a core offering that they’ve always offered. And in the past couple years,

(00:04:51)

as their business has slowed, instead of digging into the numbers and figuring out, okay, what’s really going on here? Where are our most profitable products, and where are they not? So instead of doing that and becoming a really good puzzle solver, which I have been telling my team a lot lately, “You need to become a really good puzzle solver.” Instead of looking at your, like,

you should be looking at your numbers, looking at your financials, looking at your metrics, and seeing what kind of story it’s telling you. So this particular vendor, instead of doing that, what they ended up doing is they deviated from their course so much, and went from a unique, not customized, but unique product offering, much more niche, and went more into a mainstream product offering.

And their numbers, because they’ve tried all of these new things that aren’t in alignment with their core, their numbers aren’t reflecting what they thought that they would reflect. Because many times over, we think if we just add more to the mix, or if we follow the trend of what’s happening, that is going to translate into more revenue. And we think that with more revenue, we’re going to have more profit.

And it’s the exact opposite, many times over. So we want to make sure that we stay true to the core. I have another client that constantly is bringing new ideas into the business, and especially when things are slow. So they see what other businesses in their industry are doing, and they say, “You know what? We’re going to do the same thing.” And they think that’s going to translate into more revenue. And all it did

translate into is just becoming, you end up commoditizing yourself. So you end up swimming in the sea of sameness. So if you’ve ever read the book Blue Ocean Strategy and Blue Ocean Shift, they talk heavily about swimming in a blue ocean versus a red ocean. So the way that we can do that is, again, stay true to your core. And while staying true to your core, dig into your metrics and figure out what story they’re trying to tell you.

(00:07:15)

Because there’s always a story there. There’s always a narrative there. But you have to be willing to pull those metrics. You have to be willing to pull the financials, and you have to be willing to pull all of your metrics from marketing and social media and other things that you’ve done. And then put them together. So, staying true to your core, not trying to do absolutely everything that everybody else is doing, but really figuring out what has been working,

and then going deeper on that. Number two is, this goes along with the randomness. We can test, because I’m a big fan of, entrepreneurship, having a small business, is like R&D. So we can test things. We can say, “Hey, you know what? We’re looking at our metrics, and we think this might work.” We can test, especially when it’s slow, or even when it’s busy, and we’re like, “You know what?

We want to do more of this event that we were doing, because it worked. It became very profitable for us. Our customers loved it.” We can test out things, but we can’t make it the rule. And many times over, going along with the randomness, is we want to test and test and test and test and test, and constantly doing new things, and we don’t give it enough time to stick. I have a really, really good friend of mine that says,

“You’ve got to give it 90 days. 90 days minimum.” So I always tell people, when I would work with them on search engine optimization, you do your optimization, and then you’ve got to let it sit for a bit. You can’t just tweak it every day. You’ve got to let it sit. You’ve got to let it test out. You’ve got to let it stick for a little bit. And if it doesn’t stick after that period of time, then you can change. Then you can say, “You know what, this isn’t working. We’re going to shift gears.” So we can test something new.

And I always recommend to people, just test one thing at a time. Even when you have a product or you have something that you’re selling in your store or on your menu, okay, test one thing at a time. And when we test it, we want to go back and measure it. People miss the measuring part. They just constantly want to test. They’re just testing and testing and testing. They either don’t let it sit enough

(00:09:43)

and then they abandon it too fast, or they just keep testing. So they don’t really know what’s working and what’s not working. Even if you just test it, make one very small tweak, test it, measure it. One small tweak. That’s the part that people get wrong, because they just constantly get into test mode and they don’t let something percolate. So, but here’s the other thing: when you’re constantly in test mode,

people don’t realize, you don’t realize how much that eats into your profit. It eats into your profit because you’re spending, you don’t realize the money that you’re spending putting things into test mode. It’s a new product that you have in your store, so you have increased costs getting it in there. You have new menu items, so you’re constantly tweaking to make sure that it’s working, or the plating’s right. So you’re spending extra money.

Maybe you’re even getting the flow down correctly, and you end up with a lot of waste. We don’t realize just how much time, energy, and money in our profit when we’re constantly testing new things, when we’re constantly implementing new things. We want to try one thing at a time, give it time to percolate, just like coffee. Give it time to percolate, marinate, just like vegetables.

And then make a decision what you’re going to do with it. But before you make the decision, you want to make sure that you measure it. Last thing that I’m going to give you is remember your people. At the end of the day, the most important piece to this whole thing is your people. People over profit, anytime. So when you’re constantly shooting from the hip, people don’t know what they’re working towards. They don’t know what the ultimate goal is, or what the ultimate aim is. So

what does that lead to? It leads to a lack of confusion, or lack of clarity. Confusion. It leads to people getting frustrated, because they think that they’re moving in one direction. They think they’re working on one project, and then they have to switch gears all of a sudden. And they’re constantly switching gears. So they can’t quite get their feet grounded. So if you have people who are hustling over here working on a project, and then all of a sudden you come in and you’re like,

(00:12:02)

“Okay, we’re doing this, and we’re doing this, and we’re doing this. We’re going to implement all these three things.” So then they have to switch gears and switch gears and switch gears, and nobody can kind of get their footing. And when you don’t have your footing, what happens? You end up falling, right? And people get frustrated. They get annoyed. Again, they don’t know exactly what they’re working towards. And even worse, they don’t know how what they’re doing

really matters to the end result, because they’re not totally sure what the end result is. So remember your people, especially, especially at this time of year. People, this is a very high-stress time of year, because we enter into the holiday season. The holidays are stressful to begin with, because you have all of these extra responsibilities that you need to do, extra commitments

that you have. So we want to make sure that, excuse me, as I’m choking, we want to make sure that we’re constantly taking care of our people. We want to make sure, one of the most important things that you can say to your people is, “What matters to you most?”

[Coughing.]

(00:13:21)

Oh my gosh. “What matters to you most during this season?” So,

[Coughing.]

Oh my gosh.

(00:13:38)

The theme of this: podcast host, advisor, author, live, live content creator chokes on camera. Oh my gosh. Anyway, I apologize. Thank you for hanging with me. Oy, it’s really hot outside, and it’s been really cold, and I think, like, allergies are setting in. And today, when I was on a walk,

I saw a snake. I thought my dogs were going to freak. Like, a snake just slithering along on the street. It was nuts. Anyway, I digress. This is live, people. All things happen. So, number one, stay true to your core. Make sure that you don’t implement anything random. Don’t chase trends. Don’t chase what everybody else is doing. Don’t chase what you see, what you read in the New York Times. Stay true to your core.

Stay true to what it is that you do and why you do it. And at the same time, when you’re doing that, you can focus more on the experience that you’re creating for people. Number two, test, but don’t make it the rule. If you’re going to test things, there’s nothing wrong with testing, but test one thing at a time. And don’t just put it out there. Put it out there, measure, make a tweak.

Put it out again, measure, make a tweak. And the third thing, which is most important during this time of year: remember your people. Your people are what matters most. They are the thing that brings energy and enthusiasm and aliveness into your business. Without them, you have nothing. I hate to tell you. You can have a business that generates money, but if you don’t have your people,

if you don’t have people that buy into what you’re doing and buy into what they’re doing every day, you’re going to struggle. So make sure that you take care of your people most. And like I said before I started with my coughing fit, the thing that I asked my people last year was, “What matters most to you this season? What is the thing that you want most this season?” And once they told me, we figured out a way to make it happen

(00:16:05)

for each person. And that meant more than anything else, because they got to do the thing that they really, really wanted to do that holiday season. So I hope that this helped you. I hope you have a wonderful rest of your week. Happy October. And I will see you back here next week. We have an interview with Morgan Barkas. You are going to love it.

She is phenomenal. And if you struggle with confidence, you’re going to watch that episode, because she is amazing. So I look forward to seeing you back here next week. Have a good rest of your day. Have a good rest of your week. Bye for now.

End of transcript

Next week on The Main Street CEO: an interview with Morgan Barkas.

About Theresa Cantley

Theresa Cantley is a business growth strategist and consultant who helps small to mid-size business owners step into their CEO role, build scalable systems, and breathe new life into their brands. After years in corporate America, Theresa now combines business strategy, creativity, and visioneering to help founders create sustainable success on their own terms.

Subscribe to The Main Street CEO podcast for weekly leadership, strategy, and business growth insights.

 

Ready to Get Unstuck?

Book a free call with me and let’s talk through where you’re stuck, your business needs, and how we can start building a stronger foundation for you and your team.

Book a 20 Min Main Street Reset

 

Connect with Theresa

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/theresacantley

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/theresaccantley

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/theresacantley

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@theresacantley

listen on

Do you know what kind of business owner you are?

Take this quiz to find out plus uncover your strengths and your biggest blind spots.

take the quiz →

FREE GUIDE

learn about the FREE Audio training →

Scale Your Business Faster And Get More Time Back In Your Day

Scale Your
Business Faster
And Get More Time
Back
In Your Day

free audio guide